Retired course
This course has been retired and is no longer supported.
About this lesson
Lean process improvements are designed using a “should be” value stream map that shows the new flow. The data box on this map estimates the impact of the elimination and redesign of process steps and the removal of system constraints.
Exercise files
Download this lesson’s related exercise files.
Lean Improvement: Flow.docx62.5 KB Lean Improvement: Flow - Solution.docx
64 KB
Quick reference
Lean Improvement: Flow
Lean process improvements are designed using a “should be” value stream map that shows the new flow. The data box on this map estimates the impact of the elimination and redesign of process steps and the removal of system constraints.
When to use
Lean flow improvement techniques are used when the goal of the Lean Six Sigma project was cycle time improvement. With the flow improvement, the techniques will often increase capacity, lowering total costs.
Instructions
The Lean analysis should have identified opportunities for improvement. Starting with the As-Is value stream map, the team can prioritize which opportunities to address and the nature of the changes to create a Should-Be value stream map. This becomes both the vision and guide for implementing the improvements. Many of the changes can be made independent of each other. As soon as a change is ready for implementation, it should proceed.
There are a number of Lean techniques that focus on improving the flow of an item through the process.
TAKT Time Step Design
In this technique, any step that takes longer than the TAKT time for the process is redesigned to shorten the step. When all the steps are operating at the speed of the TAKT, the process will flow smoothly at its needed capacity. One method of shortening the step is to split the step into several sub-steps, each of which is shorter than the TAKT time. In some cases, the activities at the step can be changed to a different technology or approach that is faster. If the step cannot be shortened to the TAKT time, then the step resources will need to be duplicated so that multiple items can be processed simultaneously.
Batch Size of 1
This technique is self-explanatory. The batch size of items flowing the process is reduced to the smallest possible number. Preferably one item is processed at one step and immediately moved to the next step.This approach accelerates items through the process by eliminating waiting, it makes the process more responsive to customers and is easier for process management to quickly identify problems. The challenge with this technique occurs when the step requires a large amount of unique setup for each item. If multiple items were done on one setup, it would lower setup cost and time. Implementing this technique often requires a trade-off decision between setup effort and the speed and responsiveness of the small batch.
Theory of Constraints
Dr. Goldratt developed this technique for improving process capacity by focusing the flow improvement actions on the constraining step in the process. Since the constraining step is what ultimately limits the process capacity, increasing flow through that step will increase the overall process capacity and improve flow. This technique is a five step analysis and response approach:
- Identify the constraint – Increasing capacity at any other step is pointless.
- Focus the constraint – The constraint should be doing the activities that can only be accomplished at that step. Move all other activities to other steps or resources.
- Subordinate everything to the constraint – Ensure the preceding steps are scheduled to maintain a buffer at the constraint. That way the constraint is always working. An idle constraint is lost capacity that can never be made up.
- Increase the constraint – If the step is still constraining the process, increase resources to add capacity. (Note: This is the first step requiring any financial outlays.)
- As soon as a constraint is broken, go to the next constraint – Continue this approach until the process has sufficient capacity.
Hints & tips
- TAKT time design is an enabler of many other improvement opportunities. Do this first.
- Local optimization will destroy flow. Making one step very efficient, such as running equipment 24/7 to lower absorption costs, can create havoc for flow. It's causing big bubbles of WIP. Expect resistance when trying to do Batch Size of 1 from those measuring local optimization. You must show the overall process flow and responsiveness to convince them.
- Theory of constraints can be difficult in a mixed operation where the constraining step is different for different categories of process items.
- To get the maximum process capacity and customer responsiveness, the constraining step must be actively managed to prioritize items through that step – First in, first out is not the way to manage it.
- 00:04 HI, I'm Ray Sheen.
- 00:06 Now let's turn our focus to improving the flow of the Lean process.
- 00:12 We talked during the measure stage About defining the as is process
- 00:16 now its time to create a should be process.
- 00:20 This is how we hope the process will operate
- 00:22 once all the changes are implemented.
- 00:24 The nice thing about lean improvements is that many of them are localized to just
- 00:28 a few steps.
- 00:29 And that means you can start to put them in place without needing to wait for
- 00:33 everything to go in at once.
- 00:34 So don't delay incorporating changes,
- 00:37 start getting benefits as soon as possible.
- 00:40 Some improvements will focus on flow and streamline the flow of the Value Stream.
- 00:45 I'll cover these in this module.
- 00:47 They help the process be faster, which often means lower cost and
- 00:50 more responsive to customer needs.
- 00:52 Some improvements will focus on improving quality at each step.
- 00:55 I will discuss techniques for those in the Pokeoke and the 5S modules.
- 01:00 Those improvements reduce cost, reduce uncertainty in delivery and performance,
- 01:05 which improves customer satisfaction.
- 01:07 And some improvements will focus on approving the process scheduling,
- 01:11 applying pool principles instead of push.
- 01:13 I will cover those in this module on schedule improvements,
- 01:17 these changes often give us a process that is faster, lower cost,
- 01:21 lower in the inventory, better quality, and more responsive to customer needs.
- 01:26 So let's look at the different categories of flow improvements.
- 01:29 You may not use all of these on every project, but
- 01:32 you are likely to use at least a few of them.
- 01:35 The focus of these is to reduce waste in the value string.
- 01:38 All the measurements and analysis so far, have been to find the waste, now it's time
- 01:43 to get rid of it, The most obvious, is to reduce the non-value added activities.
- 01:48 Try to eliminate these steps, or combine them to shrink them.
- 01:52 Another technique is to redesign the steps so that they fit within the TAKT time.
- 01:57 This may mean splitting some steps and
- 02:00 indicate an opportunity to combine others together.
- 02:03 If you can't get a step below the TAKT time.
- 02:05 You'll need to duplicate the workstation and all the resources so
- 02:09 that multiple units can be going through in parallel.
- 02:12 When I do that, I try to stagger the start of a unit at each workstation.
- 02:16 So that I will always have a unit completing at each TAKT time interval.
- 02:21 Another change is to reduce setup and changeover time so
- 02:24 that you can get to a batch size of 1.
- 02:26 I've been amazed at the benefits of this technique.
- 02:29 It leads to an immediate understanding of problem steps,
- 02:32 allowing further continuous improvement.
- 02:34 But more about that on the next slide.
- 02:37 Finally,apply the theory of constraints to prove total process cycle time by
- 02:41 eliminating bottlenecks.
- 02:43 Again more than that in a later slide in this module.
- 02:46 Let's talk about batch size of 1.
- 02:48 Batch size of 1 leads to huge reduction in cycle time and the level of.
- 02:53 I've seen processes routinely take weeks to accomplish.
- 02:57 Accelerate until they're only taking a few days.
- 03:00 In fact I had one manufacturing process that I was responsible for
- 03:04 go from a 2 week cycle time to a 5 hour cycle time.
- 03:07 That was of course faster and more responsive to urgent customer requests,
- 03:11 but we also found it less expensive because of less scrap.
- 03:15 We no longer had units being damaged as they were handled, and mishandled.
- 03:19 going into and out of temporary storage or holding containers.
- 03:23 The technique is self-explanatory, but there are several major implications so
- 03:27 this will work really well.
- 03:29 First, the process must be simple.
- 03:31 Think about the swim lane chart analysis.
- 03:33 I want to cross as few lanes as possible to reduce handling.
- 03:37 Also, if people or equipment are not dedicated to a particular product line or
- 03:41 an item type I need to make sure that the setup and change over time is very low.
- 03:46 Second, there's implication for process control.
- 03:49 Scheduling a tracking system must be real time or nearly so.
- 03:53 Otherwise, a preceding process step will keep slowing items to the next step.
- 03:58 And not now there's a problem in the existence of a bottleneck,
- 04:01 more about that when we discuss visual control in another module.
- 04:05 The last item I wanna talk about is constraint management,
- 04:09 this is based upon the theory of constraints developed by Dr.
- 04:12 Eilyahu Goldratt and made famous by his book The Goal.
- 04:15 The outlines of five step process for managing process constraints and
- 04:19 the first step is pretty obvious.
- 04:20 Identify the constraint.
- 04:22 This is the bottleneck and
- 04:23 if we can increase the flow through this point we speed up the entire process.
- 04:28 One of the easiest ways to do this is to watch for
- 04:31 where process items such as inventory start to stack up.
- 04:34 Something is constraining the flow.
- 04:36 Step 2 is to focus the constraint.
- 04:38 Make sure the constraint resources are focused doing the part of the process
- 04:43 that only those resources can do.
- 04:45 Offload non-essential or
- 04:47 generic activities to other resources With excess capacity.
- 04:51 Step 3.
- 04:52 Subordinate everything to the system's constraint, schedule all preceding
- 04:57 activities to provide a small surplus of improcess WIP at that point.
- 05:01 So, the constraints step is never able to get caught up.
- 05:05 Since their constraint step limits their total output from this process,
- 05:10 an idle constraint is lost process capacity.
- 05:12 Lost forever.
- 05:14 I know this is countered to some of the other lean improvement approaches, but
- 05:19 it's only a one step in the process and only for
- 05:21 a process that is capacity constrained.
- 05:24 Notice that so far after doing steps one, two and three, we've not hired any new
- 05:27 people or bought any new equipment We haven't spent any money.
- 05:31 Yet I have often seen a nearly 50% increase in process output by doing
- 05:35 those first three steps.
- 05:37 Well now it is time to spend money.
- 05:39 If the first three steps did not break the constraint,
- 05:42 add additional resources to increase the capacity of the constraint.
- 05:45 Add people or equipment to up the capacity.
- 05:49 Finally, once that step is no longer the constraint,
- 05:52 go to the next constraint and do the five steps again.
- 05:55 There is always a process constraint,
- 05:57 something limits how much the process can do.
- 06:00 Keep moving from constraint to constraint, until the capacity exceeds the demand.
- 06:06 When cycle time, cost, or flow are issues, apply these flow improvement
- 06:11 tools can significantly improve your process performance.
Lesson notes are only available for subscribers.
PMI, PMP, CAPM and PMBOK are registered marks of the Project Management Institute, Inc.